Ethical Leadership and Decision Making
A 45-minute lesson with discussion and a group poster activity
Why This Matters
Universities work with communities whose members bring different experiences, priorities, and resources. Ethical leadership means asking who benefits, who could experience harm, and who helps make decisions.
Today’s Focus
Who gets to help decide what is good for our community?
By the end of this lesson, you will be able to identify an ethical tension in a community partnership and explain how community perspectives could shape a decision.
The Case Study
In Community-Campus Relationships and the Public Good, Rebecca M. Taylor and Alice Reznickova introduce Aria James, the new director of community partnerships at Pruitt College.
Aria wants partnerships grounded in sustainability and justice.
College leaders also expect the initiative to improve recruitment, retention, and fundraising.
Funding is committed for only three years.
Aria considers three approaches:
1. Expand Internships
- Potential benefit. Support students’ careers and local economic development.
- Ethical tension. Some proposed projects could contribute to displacement or environmental harm.
2. Improve Existing Community-Engaged Courses
- Potential benefit. Support faculty, reach many students, and strengthen existing partnerships.
- Ethical tension. Quality and continuity depend on faculty time, preparation, incentives, and employment conditions.
3. Create a Sustainability and Justice Certificate
- Potential benefit. Provide sustained, focused learning and more coordinated partnerships.
- Ethical tension. Reach fewer students and risk political opposition or future funding cuts.
Aria’s Dilemma
Aria must advance justice while managing competing interests, limited resources, and relationships with people who have different priorities.
Community voices were missing from the initiative’s initial planning. Community voices were missing from the initiative’s initial planning, which raises questions about how the choices themselves were developed (pp. 197–203). (Case study, pp. 197–203)
Who Helps Shape Our Partnerships?
10-minute group poster activity · Paper and markers
Imagine you is reviewing how to strengthen an existing community partnership. Whose perspectives should help guide that conversation?
Start with Step 1. If your group finishes early, take another look at your poster together.
Ask, What might someone else notice that we missed?
If a new idea comes up, add it to your poster.
Step 1 · Map one partnership · 3 minutes
Who is connected to this partnership?
Choose a school, nonprofit, or local government partnership. Write it in the center of your poster. Around it, draw or name the people connected to it.
Reveal Step 2 · 3 minutes
Whose perspective would you like to understand better?
Circle one person or group on your poster. If you realize someone is missing, add them first. Write one question you would ask them.
Reveal Step 3 · 2 minutes
How could that person or group help decide what the partnership does next?
Add one concrete way they could help shape the partnership’s priorities.
Share One Idea · 2 minutes
This would be an example:
“We chose ___, and we would ask ___ about ___.”
Commentary Perspectives
Keep your poster in view. As we open each commentary together, consider how its discussion question applies to your partnership.
Jasmine Gurneau · Letting the Public Decide What’s Good for Them
Examine the history between the institution and surrounding communities, especially Indigenous communities. Develop priorities and partnerships through ongoing co-design and shared decision-making. (pp. 204–207)
Who helped define the problem and design the response?
Alyssa Melby · Course-Correcting for Just Community
Strengthen existing courses by giving faculty time, compensation, and recognition for their work with community partners. Direct service can meet immediate needs while students also investigate structural injustice. (pp. 208–211)
What support do the people doing this work need to sustain it?
Michael J. Rich · Institutionalizing Engagement for Stronger Colleges and Communities
Make engagement an institution-wide commitment. Connect teaching, research, and service to community priorities, and give students opportunities to take on deeper roles over time. (pp. 212–215)
How will the institution carry responsibility beyond one person or course?
Ronald David Glass · Moral Courage and the Ethics of Time and Place in Campus-Community Partnerships
Confront local histories of dispossession and inequality. Meaningful relationships take time and require accountability to the least advantaged. Leaders may need to challenge timelines and pursue smaller, slower work. (pp. 216–219)
Whose history and needs are being overlooked by the pressure for quick results?
Michael D. Burroughs · Defining and Supporting Service Learning
Clarify what service learning should accomplish and provide the structures to support it. Burroughs recommends combining campus-wide coordination, faculty development, and community collaboration. (pp. 220–223)
Do the resources and structures match the ethical goals?
Taylor Spicer · Centering a New Economic Vision to Bridge Divides
Use a shared vision of an economy that supports communities and ecological well-being. Connect campus operations, training, dialogue, community partnerships, and evaluation to that vision. (pp. 224–227)
Do the college’s everyday economic decisions support its stated values?
Reflect and Look Ahead
Return to your poster. Discuss and choose commentary that makes you think differently about your partnership. Share questions or ideas based on the perspective.
Complete this thought aloud or in your notes.
“As an educational leader, I would strengthen a partnership by ___ because ___.”
In your next case, build on today’s practice by asking how funding, timelines, and decision-making rules shape what people can contribute.
Reading source · Chapter 8, Community-Campus Relationships and the Public Good, and its accompanying commentaries in Ethics in Higher Education: Promoting Equity and Inclusion Through Case-Based Inquiry (2021), pp. 197–227.
Team: CSUSB Cohort 19 Sarai Maldonado, Carolina Carlos, Amanda Reigle
Published by Feels Like Fun ® Publishing · © 2026 Feels Like Fun®
Reading source
Taylor, R. M., & Kuntz, A. F. (Eds.). (2021). Ethics in higher education: Promoting equity and inclusion through case-based inquiry. Harvard Education Press.
This lesson draws on Chapter 8, “Community-Campus Relationships and the Public Good,” by Rebecca M. Taylor and Alice Reznickova, and the accompanying commentaries (pp. 197–227).